Hardly Reinventing The Wheel

Written by Felix Nova on Tue, Mar 1, 2016 6:30 PM
Where does Far Cry: Primal rank in the list of the most demanding games?
Rate this game User Rating
Ok Not Ok Optimisation
How well optimised is Far Cry: Primal for PC? 7.9
7.9

Back when Ubisoft announced Far Cry Primal it was met with furrowed eyebrows by one and all, along with occasional 'Ook?'. Was this another Blood Dragon? Was this is a full Far Cry sequel? We just didn’t know. As it turns out its neither of these things. Far Cry Primal straddles the divide between sequel and expansion with a certain degree of timidity, afraid to be too much of either. What we’ve got on our hands is a reasonably chunky experience, but a big question mark hangs over whether it can live up to the recent greats in this very same series.

 

Far Cry Primal loses the shackles of gung-ho military warfare and takes a very different tack - 10,000BC. Which, as the very laborious countdown in the opening cinematic will let you know, was a very, very long time ago. Guns, helicopters and even the humble wheel are but a twinkle in these cave dwellers’ eyes. It’s man versus beast and things are about to get primeval.

 

Playing as Takkar, you must battle to restore your obliterated tribe once more to greatness. Two rival tribes attempt to be the thorn in your side as you high-tail it across the lush lands of Oros, completing machines and recruiting more people to your cause. It’s that familiar Far Cry loop but in an altogether different setting.

 

A few of us been busy ploughing some time into this prehistoric adventure, and here are our thoughts.

 

 

Felix

 

Very few games have managed to make a melee first person single player game fun through the use of a close-combat game mechanic. Far Cry Primal is no exception. The melee is pretty much mash the button a few times and hope you have struck a cannibal across the head with your spiky stick. Ubisoft knows this and its game design delivers much more than a one button mash-athon.

 

A day in the life of a Neanderthal - You set your spiky club alight, throw it at a building in an enemy camp of straw huts, then watch the blaze strike chaos across the outpost as the flames jump from building to building.

From your hiding place you aim your crudely fashioned bow and pick off a few of the outlying enemies, their backs to you, as they step away from the raging blaze. You cup your hands and coo. The call summons your owl to swoop across the settlement tagging any unseen enemy. You select one that will make a meal for your animal companion; a rare Black lion you tamed a few days earlier leaps from a bush. Finally you drop down from your hiding place, a low cliff that borders the settlement, and swing your club furiously amongst the remaining enemies, while your lion pounces from one cannibal to the next.

As the quiet returns to the forest you pull a lump of meat from your knapsack and throw it to your lion.

The beauty of the forest provides the immersion and the animals within act reasonably well within it. It gives a sense that the woods are alive. When night falls I couldn't help but feel a little nervous as I heard the howls of the wolves, spotting them prowling from tree to tree on the edge of my visibility. A great touch is that once you acquire your companion, depending on where it sits in the food chain will depend on whether or not other approaching animals flee on sight or stick around to have a go with their wolf pack before fleeing when they are reduced in numbers. A hearty growl from your powerful lion can send other animals running, making you feel a lot more confident.

 

So far with the progress I’ve made I’m really enjoying the game and would give it a solid 9 out of 10. It is unfortunately missing the ability to climb trees which would have been awesome, and at times it felt a little too generous with the speed the companions were acquired, but other than that I'm having a total blast.

 

 

Jon

 

The biggest change for Far Cry Primal is undoubtedly the setting. In an age of modern warfare it’s become a bit of a rare treat to get our hands on something like this. While Ubisoft’s not exactly famous for stringently adhering to historical accuracy, in Primal they do at least go some way to building a believable world, even going so far as using a team of linguists to create a prehistoric language just for this game. Suck on that, Klingonese.

 

It harks back to a time when man and beast lived side by side and humans weren’t yet the dominant force on Earth. The Stone Age was clearly a time of great brutality and Far Cry Primal really doesn’t pull any punches. If you found the animal skinning in Far Cry 4 a little gross, this is a whole different kettle of fish. Cannibalism, body hacking and grimly realistic slayings, and that's before you've popped the kettle on for your morning brew. Violence is an everyday and unavoidable part of life in Far Cry Primal.

 

Usually you'll be the arbiter of this justice, whether taking down rival tribes or of course getting your hunt on. At its core Far Cry Primal is the hunting mechanics from Far Cry 4 blown up to the proportions of an entire game, and it means you’ll need to constantly be on the lookout for predators. You can’t just hop into a jeep and high-tail it out of there, so instead you’ve got to creep about, listen for audio cues, and try not to trip over honey badgers.

 

Yes, the honey badgers are back. For everything in Far Cry Primal there is an analogue to Far Cry 4. Towers are replaced by bonfires. Guns are replaced by spears. Grenades are replaced by sting bombs. It’s a reskinning in practically its purest form, but the fresh and unique setting will be enough to drag plenty of people kicking and screaming through to the campaign’s conclusion.

 

However, if you found yourself tiring of Far Cry 4, as I did,  then I’d probably advise giving Far Cry Primal a wide berth. If you were still itching for more then this will most definitely be your bag, and at its finest serves as a survival game for the time light. Where the likes of Rust or ARK: Survival Evolved demand hundreds of hours of your life, Far Cry Primal is the process boiled down to its absolute essentials. To that end you’ll will be working your way along a linear upgrade path, which in some respects feels as if Ubisoft copy / pasted the unlockable skills from Far Cry 4, but there’s certainly something addictive to be found in becoming the ultimate tribal warrior, building up a mighty village and commanding a zoo-full of lethal wildlife. That's not to say it's always fun, but Ubisoft sure knows how to dole out those dopamine hits to keep you chugging away, regardless of the task.

 

I absolutely adore the Stone Age setting and applaud the dev team for stepping outside it's comfort side there, but for a theme so fresh it’s a pity Ubisoft has applied a formula so stale. There is plenty to love here for those of an inquisitive nature, but the usual over-abundance of repetitive side-missions and pointless collectibles will quickly leave you feeling more like a checklist ticking bore than the primeval hunter you should be. For me this is a solid but unspectacular 6/10.

 

 

Jac

 

Ubisoft has become notorious for its copy and paste shenanigans and the Far Cry series has been a forerunner example of this alongside Assassin’s Creed, as Far Cry 3 and 4 are almost identical in the way they had you level up, take down outposts and hunt animals for upgrades. Far Cry Primal is an attempt to shatter this image of the series by stripping back the vehicle and gunplay to a mostly melee experience with a bit of Pokemon collecting thrown in.

 

There’s plenty of moments where the game really shines outside of the standard Far Cry formula. Running through the jungle with nothing but a bow, a club and spear with a bear hot on your heels looking for it’s next lunch only to run straight into a pack of wolves is the kind of gameplay the Primal setting was built for. It really makes the setting feel as dangerous and as uncivilised as you’d imagine it to be and you feel a lot more a part of the world unlike in previous games where you usually played an outsider. It’s a great feeling and it adds a lot of weight to the story which is obviously crucial in a story-driven open world experience.

 

The problems of the game come from the inescapable fact that we’ve been here before. If you’ve played Far Cry 3 or Far Cry 4 then you’ll more than likely find yourself in a state of deja vu as Primal repeats the exact same gameplay mechanics of its predecessors. Once you reach the main body of the game, you are tasked with finding flowers for healing and as you start to explore the world you have to find locations which unlock fast travel.

 

It’s a shame that Primal didn’t make more of an attempt to streamline its game design to fit with its new theme with factors like the melee gameplay being more of a clickathon than an intuitive system (think more Skyrim than Dark Souls) and that’s what keeps the game from truly standing apart from the rest of the series.

All in all, if you’re even remotely interested in the Far Cry games then you’ll be right at home with Far Cry Primal, but if you’re looking for a completely fresh experience you’re going to be sorely disappointed. Graphically the game could be a lot better when compared against other titles such as The Witcher 3 or Rise of the Tomb Raider but the prehistoric setting remains a fresh and exciting addition that I find myself excited to explore further. On the current basis I'd have to give it 7/10.

Pros

  • Incredible setting
  • Survival aspects

Cons

  • Same old Far Cry
  • Unengaging story
Score

7.5

Good

Do you enjoy this article?

Login or Register to join the debate

Rep
0
Offline
15:01 May-03-2016

The Far Cry: Primal is good but it is basically a massive hunting game. I've player far cry 3 and really enjoyed it. This game is basically a retexture of the third game with an enhanced hunting experience.

0
Rep
28
Offline
14:37 Mar-09-2016

I never knew cavemen used radar to tag threats. You learn something new every day!

0
Rep
8
Offline
09:15 Mar-12-2016

R.I.P Ubisoft

0
Rep
39
Offline
14:49 Mar-02-2016

Eh never really liked far cry too much.Its not a bad game but Eh

0
Rep
17
Offline
07:35 Mar-02-2016

And +1 for climbing trees thought. Haha

2
Rep
17
Offline
07:32 Mar-02-2016

Its a good thing that Ubisoft atleast tried to bring something new to the table. Cheers :)

4
Rep
23
Offline
05:27 Mar-02-2016

Is this game good if I've never played a Far Cry Game?

0
Rep
569
Offline
admin approved badge
05:46 Mar-02-2016

Depends on who you ask. I think it's a great game with good gameplay, graphics, performance; pretty much everything. Some people have reported errors at launch making the game unplayable (I haven't had these errors). If you want to risk these errors, I'd say get it. I'm sure Ubisoft is already working on a patch to get those errors fixed.

1
Rep
23
Offline
08:44 Mar-02-2016

Thank you...Unity was rushed out with errors. I could wait a few weeks or so to buy so that the game is ironed out. It seems like a good game.

0
Rep
970
Offline
senior admin badge
08:47 Mar-02-2016

I agree with our man Zero. Its fun and I feel its a bit different. It still has room to grow as a concept as well. I enjoy playing an occasional Far Cry game. Big open world, with lots of stuff to do. If you have not played any Far Cry game before I reckon you will really enjoy this.

0
Rep
9
Offline
03:46 Mar-02-2016

Why am i not hearing about a DX12 implementation in new games?Is it dead?

1
Rep
1,991
Offline
admin approved badge
21:46 Mar-02-2016

Developers are probably waiting for DX12 GPUs to become standard equipment for everyone.

0
Rep
63
Offline
03:17 Mar-02-2016

Huh....if this game had been released before Far Cry 3 and Far Cry 4.......It might have got a 9 or even 9.5

6
Rep
157
Offline
admin approved badge
17:37 Mar-02-2016

Same can be said for every last game in a series.

0
Rep
38
Offline
03:03 Mar-02-2016

This game should be named '10000 BC' or something :P

3
Rep
23
Offline
05:24 Mar-02-2016

I hate to break it to you...that would really just make for a really dull title. The entertainment industry probably wouldn't use it.

0
Rep
38
Offline
15:29 Mar-02-2016

IMO, Far Cry games must be full of intense gunfire as well as stealth like the ideal FC3 Game. That's where its good at. I don't really agree with an ancient civilization game named Far Cry. I mean its a great concept; but should be named something else..

1
Rep
569
Offline
admin approved badge
15:53 Mar-02-2016

Because at its core, it is a Far Cry game. If it was named something else entirely, people would be saying it is too much LIKE a Far Cry game!

1
Rep
64
Offline
admin approved badge
02:59 Mar-02-2016

I kind of wanted this game but I am afraid it will end up like far cry 4 play for a few hours get bored and stop playing. Now it is just me but far cry 4 didn't really hold my attention nothing really felt all that new.

1
Rep
16
Offline
02:31 Mar-02-2016

If you want to see a review that doesn't take into account the fact that it is similar to other far cry games, like if your new to far cry, check ACG's review out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sjYxcHQh_WM

0
Rep
12
Offline
01:47 Mar-02-2016

Yet another ubisoft disaster launch.....going to stay away from this and the division till Im confident it can play.

0
Rep
569
Offline
admin approved badge
02:02 Mar-02-2016

Depends who you ask. It runs flawlessly for me.

2
Rep
12
Offline
02:36 Mar-02-2016

yeah thats true, Im sure some people can. however it seems the majority are complaining of the same thing on steam.

0
Rep
569
Offline
admin approved badge
02:44 Mar-02-2016

Which I am sure Ubisoft is hard at work to fix. After that issue is fixed, people can only really complain about the gameplay (which is subjective).

0
Rep
12
Offline
00:43 Mar-02-2016

another franchise on its way down. such a shame :(

2
Rep
43
Offline
21:57 Mar-01-2016

Who at Ubisoft thought this was a good idea!? It has awesome graphics and an interesting concept, but ITS NOT FAR CRY.. please stop milking and ruining this great franchise, or make a new IP out of this.
Like Skyrim with guns with no guns.. or magic.. or draugrs.. or dungeons.. or dragons.. or badass swords.. or Lydia

0
Rep
132
Offline
22:01 Mar-01-2016

Ubisoft has been milking this franchise since Far Cry 2, which had nothing to do with the original Far Cry game. They just used a known name to get some sales. I'm not saying the first game was completely awesome, but I actually liked it for what it was.

1
Rep
157
Offline
admin approved badge
17:40 Mar-02-2016

Far Cry 3 was pretty solid, they really did put lots of effort into it. But milking is common a tactic among greedy publishers, make one good game than make hundreds of copies of it.

0
Rep
569
Offline
admin approved badge
00:43 Mar-02-2016

This game was actually made because of a poll that Ubisoft did soon after Far Cry 4 was released.

1
Rep
63
Offline
03:16 Mar-02-2016

Link please

0
Rep
569
Offline
admin approved badge
04:22 Mar-02-2016

Just do a simple Google search, my goodness. Click here for an article on a different website. And if I am not mistaken, Game-Debate did an article about this subject a long while back as well.


My guess is that there was a lot of people voting for "Other" and included something along the lines of FC: Primal.

1
Rep
9
Offline
03:49 Mar-02-2016

People complain that developers are miking the series but these same people are asking the devs to make a sequel to original game.That is not how it should work

0
Rep
46
Offline
19:40 Mar-01-2016

I enjoyed Far Cry 3 immensely; it was one of the most entertaining and downright fun gameplay experiences I'd had in a long time. Far Cry 4 was also very good, and the gameplay mechanics, while similar, built on what was present in Far Cry 3...but yes, it was very much the same. In between 3 and 4, I went and played through Far Cry 2 for the first time, and while much of it is similar, it was different in many ways. I do enjoy the different settings in each of the games, though, and the general feel of the game being similar, but different. ....

1
Rep
46
Offline
19:42 Mar-01-2016

.... I will give Far Cry Primal a go, eventually, but Far Cry 4 still feels fresh on my mind, and I want to give a little more time before I get into Primal.
Oh and I also want to get Rise of the Tomb Raider. I've never been huge on survival games, but both the Far Cry series and the new Tomb Raider really make it a lot of fun.
Speaking of survival, I still haven't played Alien Isolation. I'm sure that'll really make me sweat bullets playing it.

0
Rep
944
Offline
19:03 Mar-01-2016

Waste of Money :/ Happy With Rise Of The Tomb Raider :)

4
Rep
31
Offline
admin approved badge
19:02 Mar-01-2016

I am honestly bored to death with that. Ubisoft has some good engine (in terms of visuals) , a good idea for the setting but keeps using the same Core-Gameplay and game-elements in general in every title of the franchise. Sure , a franchise means that the series will have many common gameplay elements but come on , this one didnt even expand a bit upon it , I would say its a downgrade from FC4 with the lack of weapons and the smaller map!

4
Rep
15
Offline
admin approved badge
19:05 Mar-01-2016

It appears it's just another survival simulator which seems to be the new trend in video games these days.

1
Rep
15
Offline
admin approved badge
19:01 Mar-01-2016

Another survival simulator like ARK: Survival Evolved and The Forest. Go figure.


I'd rather stick with ARK unless this game becomes really cheap then I'll buy it.

-1
Rep
15
Offline
admin approved badge
19:03 Mar-01-2016

Also after the majority of problems get fixed. According to steam reviews this may as well be called Ubisoft Error Message Simulator 2016..

-1
Rep
-21
Offline
18:51 Mar-01-2016

If you wanna hear a realistic review on FC Primal watch Total Biscuit's review on youtube.
IMO this overpriced game deserves a 5/10, Assassin's Cry for Duty

2
Rep
45
Offline
18:48 Mar-01-2016

Ubisoft be like
Same, same but different :D

5